← Design · c124
completion-audit.md
Cycle completion audit
2026-10-26, for c124. A recommendation for Mark to rule on. Nothing in CYCLES.md, HISTORY.md or any CYCLE.md was changed.
Every cycle under "## Active" in cycles/CYCLES.md got a verdict: 45 design cycles plus the two cross-repo pointers (www c2, bob-wire c21), 47 in all. Each verdict comes from the status note, the CYCLE.md (whether the Outcome is written and whether the Objective's "done" is met), any PICKUP.md, and the last git touch of the cycle folder. Machine-readable copy: completion-audit.json.
| Verdict | Count |
|---|---|
| complete | 26 |
| close-superseded | 9 |
| close-abandoned | 2 |
| park | 5 |
| keep-active | 5 |
If Mark accepts every close, Active drops from 47 to 10 (5 active, 5 parked).
Two notes on dates. Several folders show 2026-09-01 because one bulk "cycle records" commit touched them that day; for c72, c76 and c78 the real work stopped in August. c105 has never been committed, so its date is the file date.
Complete
Objective met, or met in practice. Closing them means writing (or moving) the Outcome and the HISTORY.md entry.
| Cycle | Title | Last activity | Why | What closing needs | Conf. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| c65 | Control-Center v2 | 2026-08-12 | Its own Outcome already says the whole arc shipped (research, P1–P17, mocks, layer v0.9.8, qdash). | Move the Outcome to HISTORY; note the framework research feeds c123. | high |
| c70 | Thesis Kindle | 2026-09-01 | Its Outcome already says "Complete (2026-08-15)". | Move the Outcome to HISTORY. | high |
| c89 | Teams–Sessions Listings | 2026-09-18 | Outcome written; it says it was left active only for Mark to close. | Move the Outcome to HISTORY. | high |
| c107 | qdash Cutover | 2026-10-02 | Outcome written: Fable app is crates/qdash/ui, old apps tagged, STORY.md. | Move the Outcome to HISTORY. The #713 review is parked by Mark's ruling. | high |
| c88 | Global Filter | 2026-09-18 | Outcome says both phases are done (layer 0.9.13). The leftover app.qpoint.io swap targets an unused app. | Strike the app.qpoint.io step; move to HISTORY. | high |
| c80 | Brotli Stream Termination | 2026-09-01 | It waited on the qcontrol fix, which landed on main as PR #714 (5b0b028c2, 2026-09-22). | Outcome linking #714; move to HISTORY. | high |
| c99 | Nuxt Backend Interface | 2026-10-02 | Both tracks finished, the report is out, and c107 acted on the decision. | Replace "Filled at completion." with the verdict (Fable, cut over in c107). | high |
| c59 | Inventory | 2026-08-07 | Shipped to qcontrol on real data (Iteration 8, layer v0.9.6); Outcome never written. | Outcome; move to HISTORY. | high |
| c64 | Control-Center Consolidation | 2026-08-11 | All three deliverables exist and the V5 card shipped (qcontrol 376baabb). | Outcome; move to HISTORY. | high |
| c69 | Operating System | 2026-08-15 | All execution done; only its six-cycle decision queue was left, and this audit answers it. | Rule c41/c42/c44/c51/c55/c59 from this audit; Outcome; HISTORY. | high |
| c81 | Phase 1 Pages | 2026-09-09 | Done-bar was 17/17 pages on /pages/phase1: met (PR #13), plus the v2 pass. | Outcome; HISTORY. | high |
| c90 | qcontrol Preview | 2026-09-18 | All seven pages assembled; c92 then rebuilt them in the real app. | Outcome; HISTORY. | high |
| c93 | Table Column Picker | 2026-09-27 | Built, then extracted to the layer through c95 (0.9.22). | Outcome; HISTORY. | high |
| c94 | TODO Execution Process | 2026-09-25 | /todos is built and has run four sheets (c92, c102, c103, c110). | Outcome; HISTORY. | high |
| c95 | Trigger-Bar Column Picker | 2026-09-27 | DataListingBar shipped across layer, design and qdash (0.9.22). | Outcome; Figma and known gaps to backlog; HISTORY. | high |
| c110 | qdash TODOs — 2026-10-01 | 2026-10-02 | Its one plan was executed and shipped with layer 0.9.31. | Outcome; HISTORY. | high |
| c119 | Logo Downloads | 2026-10-20 | Shipped and verified live (d5a1b588b). Outcome empty. | Outcome; HISTORY. | high |
| c72 | Integrations Create & Manage | 2026-09-01 | Modal, 11 recipes, detail reuse and persistence built and checked; nothing since. | Outcome; check the Fable app kept the modal after c107; HISTORY. | medium |
| c78 | Fleet Overview Reports | 2026-09-01 | Its done-bar is met (chassis, four reports, bake-off, fleet-overview-v3). Only the picks were left, and /fleet moved to c100. | Outcome; picks go to c100, reports to c123. | medium |
| c79 | Finding Lifecycle | 2026-08-27 | The goal was to learn by building. The machine, the findings redesign and the qdash port landed; c114/c121 later re-ruled findings. | Outcome; list follow-ons as carried to the governance lab. | medium |
| c82 | Cloud Execution | 2026-09-02 | The parked experiment ran: c81 was built in two cloud runs, recorded in first-run-notes.md. | Write a short CYCLE.md (none exists); fold in orphan c83; HISTORY. | medium |
| c84 | Cycles Status Page | 2026-09-09 | The design ladder was the objective and M5 was promoted. /cycles then went the c111/c124 way, so the production slice won't happen as written. | Finish the Outcome saying so; HISTORY. | medium |
| c92 | qcontrol New Pages | 2026-09-27 | Phases 1–2 and most of 3 landed. Devices was removed (2026-09-25) and c107 replaced that ui. | Summary Outcome; mark Device Details dropped; HISTORY. | medium |
| c111 | Cycles by Week | 2026-10-05 | Done-bar met: Week view live, detail promoted to /cycles/weeks. | Outcome; hand backfill (Ph 3) and digest rewire (Ph 4) to c124 or backlog. | medium |
| c115 | Briefs | 2026-10-21 | Done-bar was one real brief used by Sarah: the sandbox brief went through to Publish. | Outcome; push main; new briefs are content, not cycle work. | medium |
| c121 | Governance v1 Scope | 2026-10-26 | All three waves built and deployed, Outcome and session decisions written; frameworks are c123's. | Confirm with Mark; carry "Not done" items to c114/c123; retire the Wave 3 PICKUP. | medium |
Close as superseded
Later cycles took the work over.
| Cycle | Title | Last activity | Why | Superseded by | What closing needs | Conf. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| c51 | App Consolidation | 2026-08-06 | The umbrella spread into child cycles, and the qdash front-end it wanted now exists. | c54, c56, c59, c61, c64, c65, c67, c68, c92, c107 | Outcome listing the children; objective 4 (docs site) to a seed; objective 5 (cookie consent) points at www c5. | high |
| c67 | Teams | 2026-08-15 | Mark ruled on 2026-09-28 that c100 pulls from these ideas; Teams shipped through c92 and c103. | c100, c92, c103 | Outcome; HISTORY. | high |
| c68 | Index Overview | 2026-08-27 | The landing question went to fleet-overview-v3, Home, and the shipped / index. | c78, c100, c109 | Outcome; HISTORY. | high |
| c41 | Signal Column Flow | 2026-05-04 | The noise-to-explanation ladder moved into the session ladder and session details. Untouched since May. | c77, c92 | Short Outcome; prototype stays at /visualization/signal-column-flow. | medium |
| c42 | Runtime Session Map Publishing | 2026-05-04 | It waited on qmap c24. qmap has moved on to c25–c28, and qmap in the product now lives in c101. | c101 | Outcome: gate never cleared, plan kept as reference. | medium |
| c55 | Agent Market Definition | 2026-08-06 | Personas moved to market-analyst (personas.json was seeded from c55), and the focus is now AI governance. | c120 + market-analyst | Outcome; copy the four open questions to market-analyst. | medium |
| c77 | Session View | 2026-08-20 | Stopped after two mocks; session detail was designed in c90 and shipped by c92. | c90, c92 | Outcome; ladder and fixtures kept as reference. | medium |
| bob-wire c21 | Inventory + Users / Devices | 2026-09-01 | Its three mocks were built here; the pages then went through c81 v2, c90 and c92. | c81, c90, c92 | Commit the folder in bob-wire (untracked there); write its Outcome; drop the pointer here. | medium |
| www c2 | Brochure Site Q2 Redesign | 2026-05-20 | Untouched since May; www c6 folds the qcontrol page into the index. | www c6 | Drop the pointer from design's CYCLES.md; let www close it. | low |
Close as abandoned
| Cycle | Title | Last activity | Why | What closing needs | Conf. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| c44 | Figma AI Dashboard Redesign | 2026-04-21 | The Figma-first plan was never followed; the redesign went code-first. | Outcome saying so; HISTORY. | high |
| c76 | Simpler Light/Dark Mode Colors | 2026-09-01 | A one-line stage-1 prompt, never kicked off, no CYCLE.md. | Drop from Active; log as a seed (or delete). | medium |
Park
Worth keeping, but not now.
| Cycle | Title | Last activity | Why | What closing needs | Conf. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| c62 | Build Partner | 2026-08-15 | Portal decisions still wait on Mark; PICKUP.md is good. "Visibility stream active" is stale: it became /partner-digest. | Fix the status note; one line in PICKUP; check bob-wire c20 is committed. | medium |
| c100 | Landing Pages | 2026-10-02 | Mocks wait on Mark's picks and a port; governance took priority, and Home moved through c109. | PICKUP.md; commit the small CYCLE.md and shot-program edits. | medium |
| c101 | Qmap Surface | 2026-09-30 | The brief has been with the designer since 2026-09-28 with no first round back. | PICKUP.md: what the designer owes, open questions, qmap Phase 0. | medium |
| c105 | Cost Center | 2026-10-02 | Round 2 was next on 2026-10-02 and nothing has moved since. The cycle and its mock are uncommitted. | Commit the cycle folder and the mock files; PICKUP.md. | medium |
| c8 | Sharing Design Philosophy | 2026-03-13 | Still a good idea, but untouched since March, and the story has changed (c117, c120, c124). | PICKUP.md: outline-v1, the open structure question, what changed. | medium |
Keep active
| Cycle | Title | Last activity | Why | Next | Conf. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| c114 | Governance Phase II | 2026-10-26 | The governance umbrella and the lab c118, c121 and c123 build in. | Refresh PICKUP.md (still says parked 2026-10-09); update object-model.md. | high |
| c122 | Early-Stage Documentation | 2026-10-26 | Phases 1–2 built; tagging next. Phase 6 is now c124's. | Tagging. | high |
| c124 | Cycle Stories | 2026-10-26 | Kicked off today; this audit is part of it. | Phase 0 inventory. | high |
| c113 | qdash Baked Demo | 2026-10-07 | One step from done: the scheduled baker waits only on Mark's R2 token. | Token → deploy → one bake → close. | medium |
| c117 | Prometheus | 2026-10-20 | Recent, with two pending source tasks and Roesler edits held uncommitted for them. | Run the two tasks, commit with the held edits, then close. | medium |
Record hygiene
Duplicate number
- c97 has two folders.
c97.gen1-originis in HISTORY.md.c97.harness-chiphas only an initial prompt and a plan (2026-09-27), no CYCLE.md, and is in neither index. No harness chip exists in the layer, so it was never built. Renumber it (next free number) and park or seed it.
Listed Active, but the record says done
- c65 and c70: the Outcome already says complete.
- c88, c89, c107: the Outcome is written and reads as finished. c89 says outright it was "left active for Mark to close".
Listed Active with no CYCLE.md
- c76: an initial prompt only.
- c82: an initial prompt, PICKUP.md and first-run notes.
Folders in neither CYCLES.md nor HISTORY.md (orphans)
- c14.northwest-passage: one PDF.
- c34.diagram: diagrams, initial prompt.
- c36.qcontrol-integration: research v1–v4.
- c73.help-overlay: a stub prompt.
- c74.component-pragmatics, c75.cycle-card-extraction: initial prompts only. /cycles now uses
CyclesCard; check whether c75 happened inside c111. - c83.layer-public: initial prompt. Answered in practice by c82's git-tag install door.
- c86.machine-status: an empty
initial-prompt.md(0 bytes). DataMachine shipped as c91. - c123.compliance-frameworks: stage 1, started today, untracked. Expected, but it needs a CYCLES.md line once kicked off.
Each needs a ruling: seed, fold into a closed cycle, or delete.
In both HISTORY and Active
- None by heading. But another session is moving cycles right now: c120's HISTORY entry and its removal from Active are uncommitted in the working tree, and c116/c118 moved today. Rule on this audit after that session commits, to avoid colliding edits to CYCLES.md and HISTORY.md.
Never committed
cycles/c105.cost-center/and its mock (app/components/cost/,app/data/cost-center-*.ts,app/pages/pages/cost-center.vue).cycles/c123.compliance-frameworks/.- bob-wire
cycles/c21.inventory/(in the bob-wire repo).
Stale notes
- c114 PICKUP.md says parked 2026-10-09, resuming 2026-10-12.
- c121 PICKUP.md is the Wave 3 hand-off, and Wave 3 is done.
- c62's status note says "visibility stream active", but nothing has moved since 2026-08-15.
- c92's status note is a paragraph-long changelog; it should be one line.
- c66 is closed in HISTORY (into c105), but its CYCLE.md has an uncommitted edit.
Cross-repo pointers
- www c2 and bob-wire c21 sit in design's Active list. Their own repos' indexes still list them as active too; www lists c1–c6 as active. Design's index should drop both pointers when they close.