[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":721},["ShallowReactive",2],{"$f0n7z1DtVVe41583Vjlv_yjHfbzLLbgGRsLZE1x7TB-g":3},{"newThing":4,"project":5,"cycle":8,"sections":23,"threads":713,"otherDocs":714,"documents":716,"images":718,"archiveItems":719,"links":720},null,{"id":6,"label":7,"liveBase":4},"design","Design",{"id":9,"num":10,"dir":11,"name":12,"title":13,"focus":14,"status":15,"statusNote":16,"created":17,"completed":4,"mode":18,"report":4,"recordless":19,"thumbnail":4,"imageCount":20,"artifactCount":21,"lastActivity":17,"hasPickup":19,"hasInitialPrompt":22},"c117",117,"c117.prometheus","prometheus","Prometheus","An ideas cycle. Gather sourced material on the Prometheus story as an analogue for AI; on ancient attitudes to fire; on David Deutsch and Karl Popper's error correction, set against our problem formation; and on modern voices about AI, from doom to salvation","active","research gathered 2026-10-20; the talk is not yet shaped","2026-10-20","assemblage (connecting myth, philosophy of science and design method, which are present but not yet linked)",false,0,1,true,[24,38,48,100,250,332],{"key":25,"title":26,"empty":19,"ast":27},"why","Why",{"type":28,"children":29},"root",[30],{"type":31,"tag":32,"props":33,"children":34},"element","p",{},[35],{"type":36,"value":37},"text","The eventual shape is a presentation of ideas (slides and a talk). Before anything is shaped, the material has to be true: quotes traced to their texts, positions stated in terms their holders would recognise, and popular misquotes kept out.",{"key":39,"title":40,"empty":19,"ast":41},"objective","Objective",{"type":28,"children":42},[43],{"type":31,"tag":32,"props":44,"children":45},{},[46],{"type":36,"value":47},"A sourced body of research that a later talk can draw on without re-checking. The talk itself is not shaped in this cycle.",{"key":49,"title":50,"empty":19,"ast":51},"scope","Scope",{"type":28,"children":52},[53],{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":55,"children":56},"ul",{},[57,70,81],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":59,"children":60},"li",{},[61,68],{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":63,"children":65},"code",{"className":64},[],[66],{"type":36,"value":67},"cycles\u002Fc117.prometheus\u002Fresearch\u002F",{"type":36,"value":69},": the gathered material",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":71,"children":72},{},[73,79],{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":74,"children":76},{"className":75},[],[77],{"type":36,"value":78},"brand\u002Ffoundational\u002Fsources\u002F",{"type":36,"value":80},": the methodology's own sources, found along the way",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":82,"children":83},{},[84,90,92,98],{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":85,"children":87},{"className":86},[],[88],{"type":36,"value":89},"brand\u002Fdesign_methodology.md",{"type":36,"value":91}," and ",{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":93,"children":95},{"className":94},[],[96],{"type":36,"value":97},"app\u002Fpages\u002Fmethod.vue",{"type":36,"value":99},": citations",{"key":101,"title":102,"empty":19,"ast":103},"key-changes","Key Changes",{"type":28,"children":104},[105],{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":106,"children":107},{},[108,130,162,195],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":109,"children":110},{},[111,117],{"type":31,"tag":112,"props":113,"children":114},"strong",{},[115],{"type":36,"value":116},"Kick-off (2026-10-20):",{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":118,"children":119},{},[120,125],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":121,"children":122},{},[123],{"type":36,"value":124},"Initial prompt captured.",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":126,"children":127},{},[128],{"type":36,"value":129},"Three research files written in parallel, plus an index. Each claim is tagged QUOTE, PARAPHRASE or SECONDARY, and each file has a \"Could not verify\" section.",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":131,"children":132},{},[133,138,140,145,146,152,154,160],{"type":31,"tag":112,"props":134,"children":135},{},[136],{"type":36,"value":137},"Methodology citation (2026-10-20):",{"type":36,"value":139}," ",{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":141,"children":143},{"className":142},[],[144],{"type":36,"value":89},{"type":36,"value":91},{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":147,"children":149},{"className":148},[],[150],{"type":36,"value":151},"\u002Fmethod",{"type":36,"value":153}," quoted Rittel & Webber (1973) without naming them. They now cite pp. 161 and 166 and end with a Sources section. Commit ",{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":155,"children":157},{"className":156},[],[158],{"type":36,"value":159},"786ebd6c0",{"type":36,"value":161},".",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":163,"children":164},{},[165,170],{"type":31,"tag":112,"props":166,"children":167},{},[168],{"type":36,"value":169},"Foundational sources (2026-10-20):",{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":171,"children":172},{},[173,183],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":174,"children":175},{},[176,181],{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":177,"children":179},{"className":178},[],[180],{"type":36,"value":78},{"type":36,"value":182}," holds annotated bibliographies of Rittel & Webber and of Axel Roesler.",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":184,"children":185},{},[186,188,194],{"type":36,"value":187},"It also holds local copies of the 13 legitimately open full texts: the UC eScholarship IURD series and Roesler's UW faculty pages. Commit ",{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":189,"children":191},{"className":190},[],[192],{"type":36,"value":193},"2ed2ad737",{"type":36,"value":161},{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":196,"children":197},{},[198,203],{"type":31,"tag":112,"props":199,"children":200},{},[201],{"type":36,"value":202},"Sources on the design site (2026-10-20):",{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":204,"children":205},{},[206,211,216],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":207,"children":208},{},[209],{"type":36,"value":210},"Two open Deutsch papers (arXiv; author PDF) were added, along with a Deutsch and Popper source list.",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":212,"children":213},{},[214],{"type":36,"value":215},"Seven photos of Roesler, Rittel and Webber were added for internal use. Rittel and Webber exist online only at low resolution.",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":217,"children":218},{},[219,225,227,233,235,241,243,248],{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":220,"children":222},{"className":221},[],[223],{"type":36,"value":224},"\u002Fsources",{"type":36,"value":226}," renders the bibliographies. ",{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":228,"children":230},{"className":229},[],[231],{"type":36,"value":232},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002F",{"type":36,"value":234}," serves the PDFs and photos (nitro ",{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":236,"children":238},{"className":237},[],[239],{"type":36,"value":240},"publicAssets",{"type":36,"value":242},"), and ",{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":244,"children":246},{"className":245},[],[247],{"type":36,"value":151},{"type":36,"value":249}," links there.",{"key":251,"title":252,"empty":19,"ast":253},"extra","Research",{"type":28,"children":254},[255],{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":256,"children":257},{},[258,270,310,321],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":259,"children":260},{},[261,268],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":263,"children":265},"a",{"href":264},"\u002Fcycles\u002Fdesign\u002Fc117\u002Fdoc\u002Fresearch\u002FREADME",[266],{"type":36,"value":267},"Index and cross-file echoes",{"type":36,"value":269},": what each file holds, answers to the prompt's questions, and open items",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":271,"children":272},{},[273,279,281,287,289,294,296,301,303,308],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":274,"children":276},{"href":275},"\u002Fcycles\u002Fdesign\u002Fc117\u002Fdoc\u002Fresearch\u002F01-prometheus-and-ancient-fire",[277],{"type":36,"value":278},"01: Prometheus and ancient fire",{"type":36,"value":280},": Hesiod, ",{"type":31,"tag":282,"props":283,"children":284},"em",{},[285],{"type":36,"value":286},"Prometheus Bound",{"type":36,"value":288},", Plato's ",{"type":31,"tag":282,"props":290,"children":291},{},[292],{"type":36,"value":293},"Protagoras",{"type":36,"value":295},", later receptions, fire-bringers in other traditions; ancient warnings about fire, praise of it, and rules for it (Trajan, the ",{"type":31,"tag":282,"props":297,"children":298},{},[299],{"type":36,"value":300},"Arthashastra",{"type":36,"value":302},", the ",{"type":31,"tag":282,"props":304,"children":305},{},[306],{"type":36,"value":307},"Zhouli",{"type":36,"value":309},", Exodus, the Vestals)",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":311,"children":312},{},[313,319],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":314,"children":316},{"href":315},"\u002Fcycles\u002Fdesign\u002Fc117\u002Fdoc\u002Fresearch\u002F02-deutsch-and-popper",[317],{"type":36,"value":318},"02: David Deutsch and Karl Popper",{"type":36,"value":320},": core ideas with page-cited quotes, Popper's P1 → TT → EE → P2, the lineage, touchpoints with problem formation (including Rittel & Webber's argument against the Popperian model), a \"Do not use\" list, and summaries at three lengths",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":322,"children":323},{},[324,330],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":325,"children":327},{"href":326},"\u002Fcycles\u002Fdesign\u002Fc117\u002Fdoc\u002Fresearch\u002F03-ai-doom-to-salvation",[328],{"type":36,"value":329},"03: AI from doom to salvation",{"type":36,"value":331},": 41 people in six bands plus reframers, dated shifts in position, collective statements and surveys, and Prometheus and fire as an AI metaphor",{"key":251,"title":333,"empty":19,"ast":334},"Sources",{"type":28,"children":335},[336,354,434,442,675],{"type":31,"tag":32,"props":337,"children":338},{},[339,341,345,347,352],{"type":36,"value":340},"On the design site at ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":342,"children":343},{"href":224},[344],{"type":36,"value":224},{"type":36,"value":346},", from ",{"type":31,"tag":62,"props":348,"children":350},{"className":349},[],[351],{"type":36,"value":78},{"type":36,"value":353},". The 15 open full texts and 7 photos are served there too.",{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":355,"children":356},{},[357,373,384,395,406,424],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":358,"children":359},{},[360,365,367],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":361,"children":362},{"href":224},[363],{"type":36,"value":364},"Sources index",{"type":36,"value":366},": each person with photo and summary, and a start-here list; local PDFs are on each person's page, and the photos with credits on ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":368,"children":370},{"href":369},"\u002Fsources\u002Fphotos",[371],{"type":36,"value":372},"Photos",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":374,"children":375},{},[376,382],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":377,"children":379},{"href":378},"\u002Fsources\u002Frittel-webber",[380],{"type":36,"value":381},"Rittel & Webber",{"type":36,"value":383},": 18 entries, with Churchman (1967) and Buchanan (1992) as context",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":385,"children":386},{},[387,393],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":388,"children":390},{"href":389},"\u002Fsources\u002Fdeutsch-popper",[391],{"type":36,"value":392},"David Deutsch and Karl Popper",{"type":36,"value":394},": books, papers, interviews, and where each can be read",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":396,"children":397},{},[398,404],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":399,"children":401},{"href":400},"\u002Fsources\u002Froesler",[402],{"type":36,"value":403},"Axel Roesler",{"type":36,"value":405},": 17 entries; Roesler chaired the 2007 thesis",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":407,"children":408},{},[409,415,416,422],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":410,"children":412},{"href":411},"\u002Fsources\u002Fbach",[413],{"type":36,"value":414},"Joscha Bach",{"type":36,"value":91},{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":417,"children":419},{"href":418},"\u002Fsources\u002Flevin",[420],{"type":36,"value":421},"Michael Levin",{"type":36,"value":423},": thinkers shaping our thinking lately, listed for themselves",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":425,"children":426},{},[427,432],{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":428,"children":429},{"href":151},[430],{"type":36,"value":431},"Design methodology",{"type":36,"value":433},": now cites Rittel & Webber (1973)",{"type":31,"tag":32,"props":435,"children":436},{},[437],{"type":31,"tag":112,"props":438,"children":439},{},[440],{"type":36,"value":441},"Papers (PDF)",{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":443,"children":444},{},[445,559,603],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":446,"children":447},{},[448,453],{"type":31,"tag":112,"props":449,"children":450},{},[451],{"type":36,"value":452},"Rittel & Webber:",{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":454,"children":455},{},[456,475,486,497,508,526,537,548],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":457,"children":458},{},[459,461,467,469],{"type":36,"value":460},"Rittel & Webber (1973), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":462,"children":464},{"href":463},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Frittel-webber-1973-dilemmas.pdf",[465],{"type":36,"value":466},"Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning",{"type":36,"value":468},"; the ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":470,"children":472},{"href":471},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Frittel-webber-1972-dilemmas-wp194.pdf",[473],{"type":36,"value":474},"1972 working-paper draft",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":476,"children":477},{},[478,480],{"type":36,"value":479},"Rittel (1966\u002F1971), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":481,"children":483},{"href":482},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Frittel-1966-some-principles-design-education.pdf",[484],{"type":36,"value":485},"Some Principles for the Design of an Educational System for Design",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":487,"children":488},{},[489,491],{"type":36,"value":490},"Rittel (1972), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":492,"children":494},{"href":493},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Frittel-1972-planning-crisis.pdf",[495],{"type":36,"value":496},"On the Planning Crisis",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":498,"children":499},{},[500,502],{"type":36,"value":501},"Noble & Rittel (1988), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":503,"children":505},{"href":504},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Fnoble-rittel-1988-ibis-for-design.pdf",[506],{"type":36,"value":507},"Issue-Based Information Systems for Design",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":509,"children":510},{},[511,513,519,520],{"type":36,"value":512},"Rittel (1969), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":514,"children":516},{"href":515},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Frittel-1969-wp115-decision-theory.pdf",[517],{"type":36,"value":518},"Decision Theory (WP 115)",{"type":36,"value":91},{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":521,"children":523},{"href":522},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Frittel-1969-wp116-instrumental-knowledge-politics.pdf",[524],{"type":36,"value":525},"Instrumental Knowledge in Politics (WP 116)",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":527,"children":528},{},[529,531],{"type":36,"value":530},"Webber (1968–69), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":532,"children":534},{"href":533},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Fwebber-1968-planning-environment-of-change.pdf",[535],{"type":36,"value":536},"Planning in an Environment of Change",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":538,"children":539},{},[540,542],{"type":36,"value":541},"Webber (1963), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":543,"children":545},{"href":544},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Fwebber-1963-comprehensive-planning-social-responsibility.pdf",[546],{"type":36,"value":547},"Comprehensive Planning and Social Responsibility",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":549,"children":550},{},[551,553],{"type":36,"value":552},"Webber (1968), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":554,"children":556},{"href":555},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Fwebber-1968-new-urban-planning-america.pdf",[557],{"type":36,"value":558},"The New Urban Planning in America",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":560,"children":561},{},[562,567],{"type":31,"tag":112,"props":563,"children":564},{},[565],{"type":36,"value":566},"Roesler:",{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":568,"children":569},{},[570,581,592],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":571,"children":572},{},[573,575],{"type":36,"value":574},"Roesler, Woods & Feil (2005), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":576,"children":578},{"href":577},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Froesler-woods-feil-2005-inventing-future-cognitive-work.pdf",[579],{"type":36,"value":580},"Inventing the Future of Cognitive Work",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":582,"children":583},{},[584,586],{"type":36,"value":585},"Roesler (2009), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":587,"children":589},{"href":588},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Froesler-2009-lessons-three-mile-island.pdf",[590],{"type":36,"value":591},"Lessons from Three Mile Island",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":593,"children":594},{},[595,597],{"type":36,"value":596},"Roesler (2011), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":598,"children":600},{"href":599},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Froesler-2011-interaction-design-high-stakes.pdf",[601],{"type":36,"value":602},"Interaction Design in High-stakes Domains",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":604,"children":605},{},[606,611],{"type":31,"tag":112,"props":607,"children":608},{},[609],{"type":36,"value":610},"Deutsch:",{"type":31,"tag":54,"props":612,"children":613},{},[614,625,636,658],{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":615,"children":616},{},[617,619],{"type":36,"value":618},"Deutsch (2013), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":620,"children":622},{"href":621},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Fdeutsch-2013-constructor-theory-arxiv.pdf",[623],{"type":36,"value":624},"Constructor Theory",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":626,"children":627},{},[628,630],{"type":36,"value":629},"Deutsch (2019), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":631,"children":633},{"href":632},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Fdeutsch-2019-beyond-reward-and-punishment.pdf",[634],{"type":36,"value":635},"Beyond Reward and Punishment",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":637,"children":638},{},[639,641,649,651,656],{"type":36,"value":640},"Deutsch (2012), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":642,"children":646},{"href":643,"rel":644},"https:\u002F\u002Faeon.co\u002Fessays\u002Fhow-close-are-we-to-creating-artificial-intelligence",[645],"nofollow",[647],{"type":36,"value":648},"\"Creative blocks\"",{"type":36,"value":650},", ",{"type":31,"tag":282,"props":652,"children":653},{},[654],{"type":36,"value":655},"Aeon",{"type":36,"value":657}," (web)",{"type":31,"tag":58,"props":659,"children":660},{},[661,666,668,673],{"type":31,"tag":282,"props":662,"children":663},{},[664],{"type":36,"value":665},"The Fabric of Reality",{"type":36,"value":667}," (1997) and ",{"type":31,"tag":282,"props":669,"children":670},{},[671],{"type":36,"value":672},"The Beginning of Infinity",{"type":36,"value":674}," (2011): books in copyright, no open copy",{"type":31,"tag":32,"props":676,"children":677},{},[678,683,684,689,691,697,699,705,707,711],{"type":31,"tag":112,"props":679,"children":680},{},[681],{"type":36,"value":682},"Photos:",{"type":36,"value":139},{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":685,"children":687},{"href":686},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Fphotos\u002Froesler-2025-manelski.jpg",[688],{"type":36,"value":403},{"type":36,"value":690}," (2025), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":692,"children":694},{"href":693},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Fphotos\u002Frittel-1959-ulm-chalkboard.jpg",[695],{"type":36,"value":696},"Horst Rittel",{"type":36,"value":698}," (Ulm, 1959), ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":700,"children":702},{"href":701},"\u002Fsources\u002Ffiles\u002Fphotos\u002Fwebber-2006-berkeley-obituary.jpg",[703],{"type":36,"value":704},"Melvin Webber",{"type":36,"value":706}," (c. 2006). All seven are on the ",{"type":31,"tag":262,"props":708,"children":709},{"href":369},[710],{"type":36,"value":372},{"type":36,"value":712}," page.",[],[715],"initial-prompt.md",[717],{"file":715,"title":13},[],[],[],1794599333758]